
Anuj Agarwal is the Group Chief Economist at Welspun World.
November 16, 2026 at 5:28 AM IST
As inflation refuses to retreat to target, central bankers are once again signalling that interest rates may have to rise further. The debate reflects a familiar dilemma: how much monetary tightening is necessary when inflation is being sustained by supply-side shocks? Falling oil prices offer relief, but cannot immediately reverse the pass-through of earlier increases in energy and input costs. Are central banks at risk of responding to yesterday's supply shock with tomorrow's demand slowdown?
This is not an unfamiliar challenge for the Reserve Bank of India. Inflation in India, as across much of the world, has been shaped by supply disruptions, geopolitical developments and commodity prices. The COVID-19 pandemic, the Russia-Ukraine war and subsequent disruptions to global energy and food markets, followed more recently by the Iran-US-Israel conflict, have repeatedly complicated the outlook. Yet the policy response has often centred on interest rates. The question is whether monetary policy is being asked to do too much.
For consumers, the distinction between demand-driven and supply-driven inflation is largely academic. Whether prices rise because households are spending more or because oil, food and other inputs become expensive, purchasing power declines. For policymakers, however, the distinction is critical because the appropriate response depends on the source and persistence of inflation.
India's Consumer Price Index series, with 2024 as its base year, highlights this vulnerability. Food and beverages account for 36.75% of the consumption basket, while housing, water, electricity, gas and other fuels account for 17.66%. Transport contributes another 8.80%. These categories are particularly exposed to weather, energy prices, logistics costs and external commodity shocks.
Although food's weight has declined from 45.86% in the previous CPI series, food and energy-related costs remain central to household inflation. Geopolitical disruptions, deficient monsoons or sharp movements in crude oil can materially alter the inflation trajectory without any corresponding increase in domestic demand.
Supply Constraints
Interest rates can moderate demand, credit growth and inflation expectations. They cannot produce crude oil, improve agricultural productivity or restore disrupted supply chains. A rate hike cannot reverse an increase in global oil prices. Its role is to prevent the initial shock from spreading into wages, services, inflation expectations and broader pricing behaviour. This distinction between first-round and second-round effects is critical.
Supply shocks rarely remain confined to the initial price increase. Higher energy costs feed into transport, manufacturing, distribution and services. Businesses may eventually pass these costs on to consumers, even when demand remains subdued.
This complicates the interpretation of core inflation. Excluding food and fuel makes core inflation a useful indicator of underlying price pressures, but does not insulate it from supply shocks. Energy and commodity costs feed into core inflation through production, transport and operating expenses. A rise in core inflation may therefore reflect the transmission of supply-side costs rather than excess demand. Policymakers must look beyond the headline number to understand what is driving it.
The RBI's October 2026 Monetary Policy Committee minutes illustrate this dilemma. The MPC raised the repo rate by 25 basis points to 5.50% and shifted its stance to calibrated tightening, even as members acknowledged that inflation pressures were largely supply-driven.
Governor Sanjay Malhotra noted that monetary policy primarily works by curtailing second-round effects, including inflation expectations and firms' pricing behaviour. Yet distinguishing these effects from the indirect transmission of supply-side costs remains difficult, particularly when both show up in core inflation.
The MPC was divided. Deputy Governor Poonam Gupta acknowledged limited evidence of inflation becoming entrenched but favoured a pre-emptive hike, citing the risk of inflation approaching the upper tolerance limit and the lags in monetary policy transmission. Two members preferred a neutral stance.
Policy Dilemma
The disagreement captures the central question: should monetary policy act on the possibility of second-round effects or wait for clearer evidence that inflation is becoming entrenched?
Central banks cannot ignore supply shocks. If businesses routinely raise prices, workers seek compensation for higher living costs and inflation expectations become entrenched, monetary policy must respond. But the opposite risk matters too. Prolonged tightening in response to temporary or reversing supply shocks can weaken consumption, investment and employment without addressing the original source of inflation.
Oil prices appear to be trending lower, while reports of physical disruptions in the Middle East have begun to ease. If sustained, these developments could gradually reduce transportation, manufacturing and distribution costs, providing relief to headline inflation. The extent and speed of this pass-through, however, will depend on several factors. Monetary policy, which operates with considerable lags, must account for changing supply conditions rather than respond mechanically to backward-looking inflation readings.
The RBI's minutes suggest that the duration and extent of tightening will depend on the underlying inflation trajectory, its breadth, second-round effects and demand impulses. This is the right framework. A supply shock warrants vigilance, but the response must be proportionate to the risk of inflation becoming persistent.
Monetary policy cannot eliminate every price increase, irrespective of its origin. Equally, supply-driven inflation cannot be dismissed as temporary if it begins to influence wage negotiations, pricing decisions and inflation expectations. If inflation broadens or second-round effects emerge, further tightening may be necessary. But if external cost pressures ease and domestic demand remains contained, the case for additional tightening must be reassessed.
Consumers bear the cost of inflation whether it originates in domestic demand or external supply disruptions. They also pay for excessively restrictive monetary policy through higher borrowing costs, weaker consumption and investment, and slower economic activity. The challenge for the RBI and other central banks is to prevent temporary supply shocks from becoming persistent inflation without unnecessarily amplifying the slowdown. That calls for neither complacency nor automatic tightening, but a measured response guided by the persistence, breadth and underlying drivers of inflation.
Views expressed are personal.